Hey, no worries. I completely understand not wanting to add every bell and whistle and keep things pretty straight forward and less bloated. Just thought I'd run it by you, never hurts to ask.
In any case, if anyone happens to come across this topic and was also looking specifically for a Subscribe2 theming option, this plugin did the trick:
http://stiofan.themetailors.com/store/products/tt-subscribe2-front-end-plugin/
Thanks, Bryan